65 Madison Ave · Suite 420 · Morristown, NJ · 07960

¡Attention TAC People!

Press 'p' on your keyboard to make this palette go away.

Max width: 1200px
Color Hex R G B
Blue from Logo#003d65 0 61 101
Darker Blue#021020 2 16 32
Red from Logo#780500 120 5 0
Darker Red#400000 64 0 0
Gray from Modern Firm Site#f3f2ed 243 242 237
Bright, Light Blue#ccebff 204 235 255
Form Input Background Blue#accfe6 172 207 230
Slightly Darker Blue#002e4d 0 46 77
Slightly Darker Gray#e6e5e0 0 46 77
Darker Gray#cccbc7 0 46 77
Lighter Logo Blue#005c99 204 235 255
Login Link Blue#598fb3 89 143 179
Slighty Lighter Red#99150f 153 21 15
Slighty Darker Gray#b3b2ae 179 178 174
Hunter Green#013b23 1 59 35
Lighter Green #025935 ? ? ?
Beige Charcoal #1f1e1e ? ? ?
"Metallic Gold" #D4AF37 ? ? ?
"Darker Green" #012e1b ? ? ?

Ladies Will You Be Able To Keep Your Engagement Ring If The Engagement Is Broken

With Valentine’s Day a couple days away, many people have purchased engagement rings with the intent of getting engaged on Valentine’s Day. As we all know, not all engagements result in wedded bliss and some people never make it down the aisle. Thus, the question remains what happens to the engagement ring if the engagement is broken.

Under New Jersey case law, the engagement ring is reviewed as a conditional gift provided to the recipient in contemplation of marriage. The condition of marriage needs to be fulfilled in order for the recipient to keep the ring. Thus, if the parties do not marry, the engagement ring belongs to the donor and not the recipient. Fault does not play any role with respect to the analysis of which party receives the engagement ring after a broken engagement as confirmed in Aronow v. Silver, 223 N.J. Super. 344 (Ch. Div. 1987). In Aronow v. Silver, there was conflicting testimony as to which party ended the engagement. However, the court confirmed that New Jersey adheres to the minority rule regarding the return of engagement rings, namely that fault is irrelevant. Therefore, even if the donor called off the wedding because he or she was having an affair, the engagement ring would still need to be returned to the donor.

Interestingly, if the ring is given on a holiday, i.e. Valentine’s Day or Christmas, the question becomes whether the ring was a conditional gift in contemplation of marriage or a plain vanilla gift. This analysis would become very fact sensitive. If the ring is considered a gift and not a conditional gift, the recipient would be allowed to keep the ring even if the engagement was broken.

If there is no wedding, then the engagement ring will need to be returned to the donor despite who is at fault with respect to why the engagement was broken. However, if you get married and then subsequently divorced, the engagement ring belongs to the recipient and is not subject to equitable distribution as the condition of marriage was met.

Begin Your Conversation

  • Disclaimer: Contacting our firm via the internet does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information through this form.

Contact Our Morris County Office

866-957-2982

973-828-0829

Morristown / Morris County Law Office

65 Madison Ave

Suite 420

Morristown, NJ 07960

Morris County Mediation Office Map